Welcome to Costella's
Costella's is a family-style Italian restaurant and market serving homemade traditional Italian cuisine in South Hill, Puyallup. See you soon!
Costella's
Italian Restaurant and Market
Review Your Favorite Dishes
Leave a Review
“Reminded me of back home in Brooklyn, I'm very glad I found this Italian restaurant, the pasta is amazing. I'll be coming here weekly!”
Ryan
“I have to admit that after spending time in Italy, as well as being raised by a spicy Italian mother, I'm always a little skeptical when a friend says "Hey, let's try this Italian restaurant!" However, Costella's delivered in a really big way! We ordered several items off the menu, but the Chicken Marsala (especially the sauce) really stole the show. A rich sauce with a perfect balance of Marsala wine and mushrooms made me feel like I was back in Sicily. Authentic and perfectly balanced! In addition to great authentic Italian food and wine, the service was top notch and had a great personal touch. This is a place that really embraces the tradition and process of authentic Italian cuisine into account. I'm looking forward to coming back and trying out the rest of the menu, in particular the cannoli and tiramisu.”
Noahjbrown
“We had the shrimp cavatelli and spaghetti and meatballs. Both were very good. The shrimp was done to perfection. We will definitely visit again.”
Kaileyab
“Randomly found this Puyallup gem and so glad I did. The food was all very fresh and tasty. The outdoor patio was the perfect spot for our evening meal and we enjoyed the whole experience. The wait staff was extremely pleasant and we felt welcome as soon as we entered the establishment. Will be back again to try more of the menu but loved the shrimp cavatelli- a perfect combo of creamy but with a nice kick at the end. The shrimp was juicy and well cooked. A perfect dinner out.”
Sarahkniery
“Delicious seasoning and pasta”
Suzanne
“Sooo delicious!! The portion was quite large, but I think it is because I didn't have enough room in my tummy. I will he back for more!”
Skatediva2000
“Reminded me of back home in Brooklyn, I'm very glad I found this Italian restaurant, the pasta is amazing. I'll be coming here weekly!”
Ryan
“I have to admit that after spending time in Italy, as well as being raised by a spicy Italian mother, I'm always a little skeptical when a friend says "Hey, let's try this Italian restaurant!" However, Costella's delivered in a really big way! We ordered several items off the menu, but the Chicken Marsala (especially the sauce) really stole the show. A rich sauce with a perfect balance of Marsala wine and mushrooms made me feel like I was back in Sicily. Authentic and perfectly balanced! In addition to great authentic Italian food and wine, the service was top notch and had a great personal touch. This is a place that really embraces the tradition and process of authentic Italian cuisine into account. I'm looking forward to coming back and trying out the rest of the menu, in particular the cannoli and tiramisu.”
Noahjbrown
“We had the shrimp cavatelli and spaghetti and meatballs. Both were very good. The shrimp was done to perfection. We will definitely visit again.”
Kaileyab
“Randomly found this Puyallup gem and so glad I did. The food was all very fresh and tasty. The outdoor patio was the perfect spot for our evening meal and we enjoyed the whole experience. The wait staff was extremely pleasant and we felt welcome as soon as we entered the establishment. Will be back again to try more of the menu but loved the shrimp cavatelli- a perfect combo of creamy but with a nice kick at the end. The shrimp was juicy and well cooked. A perfect dinner out.”
Sarahkniery
“Delicious seasoning and pasta”
Suzanne
“Sooo delicious!! The portion was quite large, but I think it is because I didn't have enough room in my tummy. I will he back for more!”
Skatediva2000
“Reminded me of back home in Brooklyn, I'm very glad I found this Italian restaurant, the pasta is amazing. I'll be coming here weekly!”
Ryan
Our Location
Hours
Sunday - Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Saturday: 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm